Skip to content
A Fall Favorite: The Original Pumpkin Seed Toffee

A Fall Favorite: The Original Pumpkin Seed Toffee

A Fall Favorite: The Original Pumpkin Seed Toffee

Cooler temperatures, leaves changing, and pumpkin spice everything…it must mean that fall is upon us. It was this time of year 10 years ago when Sweet P’s got its official start in the candy and chocolate world. Inspired by this very season, one of the first products ever created at Sweet P’s was the popular Pumpkin Seed Toffee.

Wanting a different twist on a normal product and drawing from the familiar fall flavors of pumpkin and other warm spices, this unique autumn toffee was born. Its popularity this time of year makes it extremely sought after, especially for those seeking a fall fix.

Over the years, Sweet P’s Pantry has tweaked our popular traditional toffee recipes of Butter Crunch, Cashew Almond, Sea Salt Dark Chocolate and Honey Butter Pecan to introduce other seasonal flavors such as Maple Pecan, Gingerbread, and Coffee. Our caramels also are a great canvas for seasonal flavors such as Pumpkin Spice, Lemon, Apple Pie, and Wisconsin Cherry.

No matter what the season, you can be certain Sweet P’s will capture the essence through a variety of delicious treats. We invite you to stop in and taste for yourself! So the next time you’re on a September walk through downtown Oconomowoc, grab a sweatshirt, jump through that pile of leaves and head on down to our shop for some fall favorites.

You can find all of Sweet P’s treats easily available to purchase online at Arrange for curbside pickup, local delivery or USPS shipping. We welcome your call with questions or to place your custom order by phone at 262-408-9831. Our store is also open, with limited social distancing restrictions in place. Our hours are M-F, 10 am - 5:30 pm and Saturdays from 10 am – 2 pm. 

Previous article Fall Fest Flavors on September 12th