Skip to content
Free shipping on standard orders over $100
Free shipping on orders over $100

Toffee Temptations: A symphony of Crunch and Flavor

Experience the ultimate in gourmet toffee, crafted for those who appreciate the fine balance of rich flavor and irresistible texture.
Browse our Toffee Collection
Sea Salt Caramel Sea Salt Caramel

Gourmet Caramels: Rich, Smooth and Made to Indulge

Savor the rich, buttery bliss of our handcrafted caramels, a luxurious treat for every sweet tooth.
Shop Caramel

Award-Winning Charcuterie Delights: Elevate Your Spread

Candied Pecans, Toffees, and Other Sweet and Savory Selections
Shop Charcuterie

Gift the Sweet Moments

Elevate every occasion with our curated gift boxes, brimming with award winning treats. Delight and surprise, delivered nationwide.
Explore our Gift Assortment
Free Shipping

When you spend $100+

Give Us A Call

+1 (262) 408 9831

Email

sweetp@sweetpspantry.com

Enjoy Wisconsin Favorites

Experience the Taste of Wisconsin with Every Bite!

Browse Our Sweet Collection

Featured Product

Sweet P’s Candied Pecans

Made with the finest ingredients and perfected through award-winning recipes, each pecan is lightly coated with our signature blend of flavors—creating a taste that’s both sweet and savory.

Learn More

Enjoy Our Best Sellers

Gifting for All Occassions

Corporate Gifting

Corporate Gifting

Make a Lasting Impression with Our Exclusive Corporate Gift Collection!

Contact Us
Gift Collection See more
Gift Collection See more
$ 12.95 - $ 12.95
$ 12.95
$ 12.95 - $ 12.95
$ 12.95

4 Piece Chocolates Box

4 piece assortment of our handmade chocolates Dark: Mint Mletaway, French Silk, Sea Salt Caramel, Raspberry Milk: Mint Meltaway, Irish Whiskey, Sea...

View full details
$ 12.95 - $ 12.95
$ 12.95
$ 12.95 - $ 12.95
$ 12.95
$ 23.95 - $ 23.95
$ 23.95
$ 23.95 - $ 23.95
$ 23.95

Anytime Greetings Box

Pink box with bite size treats: 4 assorted Toffee Bites, 3 Sea Salt Chocolate Caramels, 2 chocolate Hearts

$ 23.95 - $ 23.95
$ 23.95
$ 23.95 - $ 23.95
$ 23.95
$ 24.00 - $ 24.00
$ 24.00
$ 24.00 - $ 24.00
$ 24.00

Appreciation Favorites

Designed with our best sellers to show your appreciation. Includes hand written note.  Toffee Bar, Snack Size Rosemary Pecans, Peanut Butter Cup, T...

View full details
$ 24.00 - $ 24.00
$ 24.00
$ 24.00 - $ 24.00
$ 24.00
$ 5.00 - $ 25.00
$ 5.00 - $ 25.00
$ 5.00 - $ 25.00
$ 5.00

Belgian Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

Seasonal Belgian Chocolate covered all natural sandwich cookies. Everyone's Favorite.

$ 5.00 - $ 25.00
$ 5.00 - $ 25.00
$ 5.00 - $ 25.00
$ 5.00
View More

Testimonials

Our company orders from Sweet P's Pantry for holiday gifts and Administrative Professionals Day and we couldn't be happier with the level of service we've gotten. Thank you to the whole Sweet P's Pantry team for being great at what you do.

Etta L.

The Ruby chocolate is pure heaven!!! It is truly unique and one of a kind, so incredible! The owners are so genuine, intelligent and amazing chocolatiers!!!

Michelle V.

We were visiting the Oconomowoc Christmas German fest and happened into this shop from the signage. I have to say customer service and charisma for miles! This is what is missing anywhere else you go :)! If you're in the area, visit this gem of a shop!

Jennifer H.

Add customer reviews and testimonials to showcase your store's happy customers.

Author's name

Add customer reviews and testimonials to showcase your store's happy customers.

Author's name

Add customer reviews and testimonials to showcase your store's happy customers.

Author's name

The Sweet Spot: What's New and News

  • Custom Gift Boxes for Customers, Clients and Employees

    Elevate Your Corporate Gifting with Sweet P’s Pantry

    Make this gifting season count with Sweet P’s Pantry. Our handcrafted confections are more than just sweets—they’re a statement. Show your clients, partners, and employees that you care with a gift that’s crafted with love, attention to detail, and a commitment to excellence. Because when it comes to making an impression, sweet is always the way to go.
    Read now
  • Indulge in Our Summer Favorite Pecans

    Indulge in Our Summer Favorite Pecans

    Sweet P's Pantry loves its summer favorite candied pecans: Rosemary Salt & Pepper, Margarita, and Spiced Orange. These treats are perfect for elevating your summer outings, from backyard BBQs to beach trips. Rosemary Salt & Pepper offers a Mediterranean flavor, Margarita brings a playful twist, and Spiced Orange provides a sophisticated taste. Each flavor pairs excellently with different beverages, such as beer, wine, or kombucha. Available in various packaging sizes, these award-winning pecans are perfect for snacking or sharing. Visit Sweet P's Pantry to order your favorite summer pecans and make your gatherings unforgettable.
    Read now
See more

Search

Use this section to help customers find the products they're looking for.