Gifts under $25

Why choose just one flavor when you can have them all? Our Toffee Sampler Bar is perfect for toffee lovers who want to experience the full range of...

Treat yourself to the ultimate indulgence with our award-winning Toffee Bars, crafted to perfection and celebrated at the Wisconsin State Fair and ...

Delight in a variety of our finest toffees with the Toffee Bite Assortment—the perfect gift for sharing or savoring on your own! Each assortment fe...

Indulge in Sweet P’s Toffee Collection, where toffee is our specialty. Crafted from all-natural ingredients like rich Wisconsin butter, premium Bel...

Experience indulgence at its finest with our Toffee Gift Box, featuring an irresistible assortment of award-winning, handcrafted toffees. Made in s...

Say hello to the snack that stole the show at the 2025 Wisconsin State Fair. Our Toffee Pretzel Bark is a 6 oz celebration of everything salty, swe...

Indulge in the irresistible flavor of handcrafted perfection with our Toffee Popcorn and Toffee Pretzels, where our award-winning, all-natural toff...

Please note: Warm Weather Special Packaging charge of an additional $7.50 is available: your order will be packed with insulation and frozen gel pa...

Indulge in the elevated taste of the WISCO Bar Delux—a premium chocolate experience that celebrates the flavors of Wisconsin with refined elegance....

Celebrate the Badger State with our Wisconsin Chocolate Bar, a delightful tribute to Wisconsin’s beloved shape crafted from premium Belgian chocola...

Discover the irresistible charm of our WI Cherry Caramels, a 2019 State Fair Ribbon Winner that has become a favorite for caramel lovers everywhere...