Skip to content

Gifts under $25

Original price $ 22.00 - Original price $ 22.00
Original price
$ 22.00
$ 22.00 - $ 22.00
Current price $ 22.00

Sweet Favorites Gift Box

These gift boxes are designed with our best sellers to show your appreciation. Includes hand written note. Sweet Favorites 1: Toffee Bar, Snack Siz...

View full details
Original price $ 22.00 - Original price $ 22.00
Original price
$ 22.00
$ 22.00 - $ 22.00
Current price $ 22.00
Original price $ 7.25 - Original price $ 18.00
Original price
$ 7.25 - $ 18.00
$ 7.25 - $ 18.00
Current price $ 7.25

Sweet P’s Pantry’s Candied Pecans: The Ultimate Snack and Gourmet Ingredient

Craving a snack that’s as versatile as it is delicious? Meet Sweet P’s Pantry’s Candied Pecans—your new go-to for everything from gourmet salads to...

View full details
Original price $ 7.25 - Original price $ 18.00
Original price
$ 7.25 - $ 18.00
$ 7.25 - $ 18.00
Current price $ 7.25
Original price $ 24.00 - Original price $ 24.00
Original price
$ 24.00
$ 24.00 - $ 24.00
Current price $ 24.00

Sweet Thank You Gift Box

Show your appreciation with our Sweet Thank You Gift Box, a thoughtful collection of treats that makes saying "thank you" a little sweeter. Whether...

View full details
Original price $ 24.00 - Original price $ 24.00
Original price
$ 24.00
$ 24.00 - $ 24.00
Current price $ 24.00
Original price $ 14.95 - Original price $ 14.95
Original price
$ 14.95
$ 14.95 - $ 14.95
Current price $ 14.95

Thank You 6x6 Box

Express your gratitude with the Thank You 6x Gift Box, a curated selection of sweet treats designed to make saying "thank you" extra special. Perfe...

View full details
Original price $ 14.95 - Original price $ 14.95
Original price
$ 14.95
$ 14.95 - $ 14.95
Current price $ 14.95
Original price $ 3.00 - Original price $ 235.00
Original price
$ 3.00 - $ 235.00
$ 3.00 - $ 235.00
Current price $ 3.00

Thank You Bars

Say "thank you" in the sweetest way with our Belgian Chocolate Thank You Bars! Made from premium milk or dark Belgian chocolate, each 1.2 oz bar is...

View full details
Original price $ 3.00 - Original price $ 235.00
Original price
$ 3.00 - $ 235.00
$ 3.00 - $ 235.00
Current price $ 3.00
Original price $ 6.95 - Original price $ 78.00
Original price
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
Current price $ 6.95

Thanks For Your Business Gift Box

Show your gratitude this Thanksgiving with our Thank You for Your Business Gift Box—a thoughtful, seasonal gesture to express appreciation to value...

View full details
Original price $ 6.95 - Original price $ 78.00
Original price
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
Current price $ 6.95
Original price $ 6.95 - Original price $ 78.00
Original price
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
Current price $ 6.95

Thanksgiving Petite Treat Gift Boxes

Celebrate the season of gratitude with our Thanksgiving Petite Treat Gift Box—a perfectly sized gift to say "Happy Thanksgiving" in a sweet and mem...

View full details
Original price $ 6.95 - Original price $ 78.00
Original price
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
$ 6.95 - $ 78.00
Current price $ 6.95
Original price $ 3.00 - Original price $ 69.00
Original price
$ 3.00 - $ 69.00
$ 3.00 - $ 69.00
Current price $ 3.00

Thinking of You

Show someone you care with our Thinking of You Chocolate Bar—a sweet and thoughtful way to let them know they're on your mind. Made from rich, prem...

View full details
Original price $ 3.00 - Original price $ 69.00
Original price
$ 3.00 - $ 69.00
$ 3.00 - $ 69.00
Current price $ 3.00
Original price $ 20.00 - Original price $ 59.00
Original price
$ 20.00 - $ 59.00
$ 20.00 - $ 59.00
Current price $ 20.00

Toffee Bar Sampler

Why choose just one flavor when you can have them all? Our Toffee Sampler Bar is perfect for toffee lovers who want to experience the full range of...

View full details
Original price $ 20.00 - Original price $ 59.00
Original price
$ 20.00 - $ 59.00
$ 20.00 - $ 59.00
Current price $ 20.00
Original price $ 18.00 - Original price $ 59.95
Original price
$ 18.00 - $ 59.95
$ 18.00 - $ 59.95
Current price $ 18.00

Toffee Bars

Treat yourself to the ultimate indulgence with our award-winning Toffee Bars, crafted to perfection and celebrated at the Wisconsin State Fair and ...

View full details
Original price $ 18.00 - Original price $ 59.95
Original price
$ 18.00 - $ 59.95
$ 18.00 - $ 59.95
Current price $ 18.00
Original price $ 9.95 - Original price $ 120.00
Original price
$ 9.95 - $ 120.00
$ 9.95 - $ 120.00
Current price $ 9.95

Toffee Bites Assortment

Delight in a variety of our finest toffees with the Toffee Bite Assortment—the perfect gift for sharing or savoring on your own! Each assortment fe...

View full details
Original price $ 9.95 - Original price $ 120.00
Original price
$ 9.95 - $ 120.00
$ 9.95 - $ 120.00
Current price $ 9.95
Original price $ 9.95 - Original price $ 36.00
Original price
$ 9.95 - $ 36.00
$ 9.95 - $ 36.00
Current price $ 9.95

Toffee Box Collection

Indulge in Sweet P’s Toffee Collection, where toffee is our specialty. Crafted from all-natural ingredients like rich Wisconsin butter, premium Bel...

View full details
Original price $ 9.95 - Original price $ 36.00
Original price
$ 9.95 - $ 36.00
$ 9.95 - $ 36.00
Current price $ 9.95
Original price $ 20.00 - Original price $ 44.50
Original price
$ 20.00 - $ 44.50
$ 20.00 - $ 44.50
Current price $ 20.00

Toffee Gift Box

Delight in the ultimate toffee experience with our Toffee Gift Box, a luxurious selection of award-winning flavors crafted with Grade AA Wisconsin ...

View full details
Original price $ 20.00 - Original price $ 44.50
Original price
$ 20.00 - $ 44.50
$ 20.00 - $ 44.50
Current price $ 20.00
Original price $ 6.25 - Original price $ 6.25
Original price
$ 6.25
$ 6.25 - $ 6.25
Current price $ 6.25

Toffee Pretzels & Popcorn

Indulge in the irresistible flavor of handcrafted perfection with our Toffee Popcorn and Toffee Pretzels, where our award-winning, all-natural toff...

View full details
Original price $ 6.25 - Original price $ 6.25
Original price
$ 6.25
$ 6.25 - $ 6.25
Current price $ 6.25
Original price $ 8.50 - Original price $ 96.00
Original price
$ 8.50 - $ 96.00
$ 8.50 - $ 96.00
Current price $ 8.50

Valentine Treat Bag

Toffee Bar and Chocolate Heart for all of your sweeties, friends and clients.Great Client Gift!

Original price $ 8.50 - Original price $ 96.00
Original price
$ 8.50 - $ 96.00
$ 8.50 - $ 96.00
Current price $ 8.50
Original price $ 7.50 - Original price $ 7.50
Original price
$ 7.50
$ 7.50 - $ 7.50
Current price $ 7.50

Warm Weather Special Packaging

Please note: Warm Weather Special Packaging charge of an additional $7.50 is available: your order will be packed with insulation and frozen gel pa...

View full details
Original price $ 7.50 - Original price $ 7.50
Original price
$ 7.50
$ 7.50 - $ 7.50
Current price $ 7.50
Original price $ 11.95 - Original price $ 11.95
Original price
$ 11.95
$ 11.95 - $ 11.95
Current price $ 11.95

Wisconsin Cherry Caramels

Discover the irresistible charm of our WI Cherry Caramels, a 2019 State Fair Ribbon Winner that has become a favorite for caramel lovers everywhere...

View full details
Original price $ 11.95 - Original price $ 11.95
Original price
$ 11.95
$ 11.95 - $ 11.95
Current price $ 11.95
Original price $ 4.25 - Original price $ 32.00
Original price
$ 4.25 - $ 32.00
$ 4.25 - $ 32.00
Current price $ 4.25

Wisconsin Chocolate Bars

Celebrate the Badger State with our Wisconsin Chocolate Bar, a delightful tribute to Wisconsin’s beloved shape crafted from premium Belgian chocola...

View full details
Original price $ 4.25 - Original price $ 32.00
Original price
$ 4.25 - $ 32.00
$ 4.25 - $ 32.00
Current price $ 4.25
Original price $ 24.95 - Original price $ 24.95
Original price
$ 24.95
$ 24.95 - $ 24.95
Current price $ 24.95

Wisconsin-Inspired Supper Club Chocolate Flight

Indulge in a taste of Wisconsin’s supper club tradition with our Supper Club Cocktail Cremes. Perfect for gifting or savoring, this 6-piece assortm...

View full details
Original price $ 24.95 - Original price $ 24.95
Original price
$ 24.95
$ 24.95 - $ 24.95
Current price $ 24.95