Gifts under $25

Indulge in the ultimate treat for peanut butter lovers with our Peanut Butter Heart! This 4-inch heart-shaped confection is filled with rich, cream...

Indulge in the perfect combination of premium chocolate and quality ingredients with our Chocolate Clusters. These bite-sized nibbles are expertly ...

Discover a one-of-a-kind flavor experience with our Ruby Cherry Almond Toffee! Crafted from the finest ingredients—grade AA Wisconsin butter, tart ...

Indulge in the perfect blend of sweet and salty with our Sea Salt Caramels. Handcrafted from creamy Wisconsin butter and cream, these caramels are ...

Ready to elevate your snacking game? Our Seasonal Pecan Sampler is the ultimate sidekick for your charcuterie tray, salads, or whenever you need a ...

Toffee Bar and Chocolate Heart for all of your sweeties, friends and clients.

Craving a delicious snack that fits your healthy lifestyle? Sharay's Ghana Style Brittle is here to satisfy! This crunchy, artisanal brittle is mad...

Indulge in a rich, luxurious sipping experience with our Sipping Chocolate, crafted from shaved dark and white Belgian chocolate. Perfect for mixin...

The Small Treats Gift Bag is the perfect way to express gratitude or celebrate a special occasion. Thoughtfully curated and elegantly packaged, thi...

Get ready for a bold flavor journey with our Smokey Maple Candied Pecans—where the rich, smoky essence of the Northwoods meets the sweet, indulgent...

Elevate your snacking with our award-winning Spiced Orange Candied Pecans! Infused with natural orange oil, ginger, and a blend of warm spices, the...

Our 8oz Sponge Candy is the perfect treat for anyone who loves a light, crispy crunch wrapped in smooth, creamy chocolate. Available in both milk a...

Craving a snack that’s as versatile as it is delicious? Meet Sweet P’s Pantry’s Candied Pecans—your new go-to for everything from gourmet salads to...

Show your appreciation with our Sweet Thank You Gift Box, a thoughtful collection of treats that makes saying "thank you" a little sweeter. Whether...

Express your gratitude with the Thank You 6x Gift Box, a curated selection of sweet treats designed to make saying "thank you" extra special. Perfe...

Say "thank you" in the sweetest way with our Belgian Chocolate Thank You Bars! Made from premium milk or dark Belgian chocolate, each 1.2 oz bar is...

Show your gratitude this Thanksgiving with our Thank You for Your Business Gift Box—a thoughtful, seasonal gesture to express appreciation to value...

Celebrate the season of gratitude with our Thanksgiving Petite Treat Gift Box—a perfectly sized gift to say "Happy Thanksgiving" in a sweet and mem...

Show someone you care with our Thinking of You Chocolate Bar—a sweet and thoughtful way to let them know they're on your mind. Made from rich, prem...

Why choose just one flavor when you can have them all? Our Toffee Sampler Bar is perfect for toffee lovers who want to experience the full range of...

Treat yourself to the ultimate indulgence with our award-winning Toffee Bars, crafted to perfection and celebrated at the Wisconsin State Fair and ...

Delight in a variety of our finest toffees with the Toffee Bite Assortment—the perfect gift for sharing or savoring on your own! Each assortment fe...

Indulge in Sweet P’s Toffee Collection, where toffee is our specialty. Crafted from all-natural ingredients like rich Wisconsin butter, premium Bel...