Gifts between $25 and $50

Indulge in the perfect blend of sweet and salty with our Sea Salt Caramels. Handcrafted from creamy Wisconsin butter and cream, these caramels are ...

Celebrate your love for the Green Bay Packers with our exclusive Packer Chocolates, crafted with care right here in Wisconsin! These premium Belgia...

Organic Peppermint is infused in our premium chocolate Mint Meltaways. Melt in your mouth creaminess, perfect for after dinner, or anytime.

Indulge in pure luxury with our 16 pc. Chocolates & Truffles Assortment! Made with natural ingredients, our assortment includes mouth-watering ...

Craving a delicious snack that fits your healthy lifestyle? Sharay's Ghana Style Brittle is here to satisfy! This crunchy, artisanal brittle is mad...

Indulge in Sweet P’s Toffee Collection, where toffee is our specialty. Crafted from all-natural ingredients like rich Wisconsin butter, premium Bel...

Celebrate the Badger State with our Wisconsin Chocolate Bar, a delightful tribute to Wisconsin’s beloved shape crafted from premium Belgian chocola...

Express your gratitude in the most delicious way with our Thank You Chocolate Box, available in your choice of milk or dark chocolate. Perfect for ...

Treat yourself to the ultimate indulgence with our award-winning Toffee Bars, crafted to perfection and celebrated at the Wisconsin State Fair and ...

Celebrate the best of Wisconsin with our WI State Fair Winner Gift Box, featuring a curated selection of Sweet P’s award-winning treats, each recog...

Discover why these treats made Sweet P’s famous. Our Best Sellers Gift Box brings together customer favorites and award-winning flavors — the perfe...

Pre-order for delivery between November 15 and December 1 or choose in-store pickup.Celebrate the season with our 12 Days of Christmas Chocolate Bo...

Sweet P’s Classic Assortment is our top-selling gift box, beloved for its perfect blend of signature treats. Beautifully packaged and ready for gif...

Express your gratitude with our Thank You Gift Tote, a deliciously curated selection of Sweet P’s favorites that says "thank you" in the sweetest w...

Our Gluten-Free Gift Box is a curated selection of indulgent, gluten-free treats crafted for those who follow a gluten-free lifestyle. Each item is...

Experience the true taste of Wisconsin with our Wisconsin Cherry Gift Box, where local dried cherries take center stage. Perfect for cherry lovers,...

Indulge yourself or surprise someone special with the Pecan Lover’s Gift Box—the ultimate treat for any true pecan enthusiast. This gourmet gift b...

Make your fall celebrations sweeter )and way more fun) with our Chocolate Pumpkin Piñata. Crafted from rich Belgian chocolate and decorated with fe...

These gift boxes are designed with our best sellers to show your appreciation. Includes hand written note. Sweet Favorites 1: Toffee Bar, Snack Siz...

Send a heartfelt message with our Hearts and Toffee gift box—a delightful mix of love and indulgence. This charming box includes: 8 Belgian Choco...

Indulge in the bold, nutty flavors of Sharay’s Ghana Style Brittle Variety Pack, crafted with our signature recipe for a perfectly crunchy treat th...

Yippee! Congratulate someone on something well done! Includes:8 oz. Cashew Almond ToffeeToffee PopcornBelgian Chocolate Congratulations bar

Discover the best of Sweet P’s with our Sweet P Sampler Gift Box—a delightful collection of our most popular treats, thoughtfully packaged in small...

A cheery snowman in premium Belgian chocolate. Available in Milk or Dark.  3 1/2 inches tall.