Chocolate Easter Eggs

Easter just isn’t Easter without a proper chocolate egg and at Sweet P’s, ours are filled to be remembered.

Our handmade filled chocolate Easter eggs are crafted in small batches using smooth Belgian chocolate and generously filled with our signature centers. These gourmet Easter eggs combine a rich chocolate shell with creamy, indulgent fillings, creating the classic chocolate Easter eggs customers return for every spring.

Sweet P’s filled Easter eggs are a seasonal tradition in Wisconsin, the Easter basket chocolate eggs families look for year after year. Each egg is carefully made by hand to deliver the perfect balance of chocolate and filling in every bite.

Perfect for Easter baskets, gifting, spring celebrations, or simply enjoying your favorite handmade Easter candy.

Reserve Window: Because these eggs are made in limited batches, we offer a Reserve Window from March 9 through March 27 to secure your favorites before Easter week.

Pick Up: Reserved orders will be available for pickup March 30 through April 4, perfectly timed for Easter baskets and celebrations.

Perfect for Easter baskets, gifting, spring gatherings, or simply enjoying your favorite handmade Easter candy.

Available Flavors (2026 Selection)

• Peanut Butter – Creamy, smooth peanut butter wrapped in Belgian chocolate. A Sweet P’s classic that always disappears first.
• Buttercream – Soft, vanilla-kissed buttercream with delicate sweetness, enrobed in rich chocolate. Pure Easter nostalgia.
• Caramel – Buttery, slow-cooked caramel with a soft melt-in-the-center bite. Sweet, comforting, and deeply satisfying.
• Maple Pecan – Sweet maple cream blended with toasted pecans for a warm, nutty crunch. A signature Sweet P’s flavor.
• Raspberry – Bright raspberry cream with a gentle fruit tang, coated in smooth chocolate. Light, vibrant, and spring-perfect.