Sweet P’s Supper Club Flight: A Toast to Wisconsin Tradition

Wisconsin supper clubs aren’t just restaurants—they’re institutions. These cozy, family-owned gems have been dishing up prime rib, walleye, and relish trays for nearly a century. And let’s not forget the iconic Brandy Old Fashioned, the crown jewel of every supper club bar. From the scenic Ishnala Supper Club in Wisconsin Dells, perched above Mirror Lake, to the historic HobNob in Racine, and the charming Schwarz’s Supper Club in St. Anna, these establishments are synonymous with warm hospitality, hearty meals, and craft cocktails that stand the test of time.

At Sweet P’s Pantry, we’re raising a toast to this rich tradition with our Supper Club Flight—a collection of six indulgent, cocktail-inspired confections. Our chocolates pay homage to the classic supper club drink lineup: Brandy Old Fashioned, Bourbon Balls, Mudslide, Brandy Alexander, Grasshopper, and Pink Squirrel. Each piece captures the essence of these legendary cocktails in sweet, bite-sized form. Not to brag, but we think they’re just as timeless as the supper clubs that inspired them. And while the Brandy Old Fashioned reigns supreme, many clubs also offer stellar craft cocktails like the Manhattan, Whiskey Sour, and classic martinis—perfect complements to the nostalgic flavors in our flight.

Whether you’re shopping for the cocktail lover in your life or just looking for a treat that screams "Wisconsin charm," our Supper Club Flight is available all year long. Plus, we’ve made gifting even easier with our 2-piece and 6-piece Brandy Old Fashioned and Bourbon Ball boxes—ideal for hostess gifts, birthdays, or as a sweet surprise to say, "You’re Old Fashioned-perfect." Seriously, who wouldn’t want a taste of supper club magic delivered in a chocolate box?

From the roaring fireplaces of supper clubs to your cozy kitchen table, Sweet P’s Supper Club Flight is a celebration of Wisconsin’s culinary and cocktail heritage. Stop by or shop online to grab your flight today, and let’s keep this delicious tradition alive—one chocolate (or Old Fashioned) at a time.