Taste of Wisconsin
From Cherry Almond Toffee to 'I Love Wisconsin' Chocolate Bars, Our Homegrown Products Celebrate Wisconsin's Rich Flavors
Search
Use this section to help customers find the products they're looking for.
Browse Our Sweet Collection
Enjoy Our Best Sellers
16 Piece Truffle Assortment
Treat yourself or loved one to the finest chocolates and truffles.
Ruby Cherry Almond Toffee
Made with Door County Cherries, AA Wisconsin Butter and Roasted Almonds
Sweet P's Classic Assortment
A delicious combo of toffees, caramels, truffles cluster and all natural peanut butter cup.
Best Seller Gift Box
Award winning Pecans, Cherry Caramels and Toffee Bites
Gifts Under $25
Original price
$ 12.95
-
Original price
$ 12.95
Original price
$ 12.95
$ 12.95
-
$ 12.95
Current price
$ 12.95
4 Piece Chocolates Box
4 piece assortment of our handmade chocolates Dark: Mint Mletaway, French Silk, Sea Salt Caramel, Raspberry Milk: Mint Meltaway, Irish Whiskey, Sea...
View full details
Original price
$ 12.95
-
Original price
$ 12.95
Original price
$ 12.95
$ 12.95
-
$ 12.95
Current price
$ 12.95
Original price
$ 23.95
-
Original price
$ 23.95
Original price
$ 23.95
$ 23.95
-
$ 23.95
Current price
$ 23.95
Anytime Greetings Box
Pink box with bite size treats: 4 assorted Toffee Bites, 3 Sea Salt Chocolate Caramels, 2 chocolate Hearts
Original price
$ 23.95
-
Original price
$ 23.95
Original price
$ 23.95
$ 23.95
-
$ 23.95
Current price
$ 23.95
Original price
$ 24.00
-
Original price
$ 24.00
Original price
$ 24.00
$ 24.00
-
$ 24.00
Current price
$ 24.00
Appreciation Favorites
Designed with our best sellers to show your appreciation. Includes hand written note. Toffee Bar, Snack Size Rosemary Pecans, Peanut Butter Cup, T...
View full details
Original price
$ 24.00
-
Original price
$ 24.00
Original price
$ 24.00
$ 24.00
-
$ 24.00
Current price
$ 24.00
Original price
$ 7.25
-
Original price
$ 18.00
Original price
$ 7.25
-
$ 18.00
$ 7.25
-
$ 18.00
Current price
$ 7.25
Award Winning Margarita Pecans
Seriously addictive. Lime and a touch of Chipotle spice up these candied pecans. 2018 State Fair Ribbon Winner.
Original price
$ 7.25
-
Original price
$ 18.00
Original price
$ 7.25
-
$ 18.00
$ 7.25
-
$ 18.00
Current price
$ 7.25
Testimonials
Our company orders from Sweet P's Pantry for holiday gifts and Administrative Professionals Day and we couldn't be happier with the level of service we've gotten. Thank you to the whole Sweet P's Pantry team for being great at what you do.
Etta L.
The Ruby chocolate is pure heaven!!! It is truly unique and one of a kind, so incredible! The owners are so genuine, intelligent and amazing chocolatiers!!!
Michelle V.
We were visiting the Oconomowoc Christmas German fest and happened into this shop from the signage. I have to say customer service and charisma for miles! This is what is missing anywhere else you go :)! If you're in the area, visit this gem of a shop!
Jennifer H.
Add customer reviews and testimonials to showcase your store's happy customers.
Author's name
Add customer reviews and testimonials to showcase your store's happy customers.
Author's name
Add customer reviews and testimonials to showcase your store's happy customers.
Author's name
The Sweet Spot: What's' New and News
-
A Whole New Way to Enjoy Highlander Grogg: The Toffee Bar!
Read nowHey there, toffee lovers! We've got some exciting news to share: our beloved Highlander Grogg Toffee is now available in a handy 2 oz bar size. Yep, you heard that right – it's the same tasty treat you know and...
-
Get Egg-cited: Flavor-Packed Filled Chocolate Eggs Await at Sweet P’s Pantry!
Experience an unforgettable Easter with Sweet P’s Pantry! Our filled chocolate eggs promise a delectable journey through flavors like creamy peanut butter and zesty raspberry bursts. Crafted with care and premium ingredients, these eggs are a true delight for any chocolate lover. Whether you’re treating yourself or searching for the perfect Easter gift, Sweet P’s Pantry has what you need. Don’t miss out—hop over today and indulge in a slice of chocolatey paradise!Read now -
Sweet P's Toffees: From Award-Winning Flavors to Perfect Pairings
Read nowHey Sweet P's fam! Our toffees are not just any toffees; they're award-winners that have been stealing hearts since 2014. From the classic Butter Crunch to the exotic Ruby Cherry Almond, we've got a lineup that's bound to make your...